Sign In

 

 

Pergo reacts to misleading press release of Classen regarding Pergo-Classen disputePergo reacts to misleading press release of Classen regarding Pergo-Classen dispute2017-04-26T22:00:00Z

On March 23, 2017, the first instance court in Dusseldorf, Germany, handed down two decisions in a legal dispute involving Pergo and Classen, relating to both parties' patent cooperation on Fold-Down technology.  

In the first case brought by Pergo, it was decided that Classen breached certain fundamental clauses of the Pergo-Classen agreement, and that as a result, Classen is liable to compensate Pergo for damages. The court ordered Classen to provide information to Pergo, so that Pergo could quantify its past damages. 

Classen counterclaimed and argued that Pergo did not have the right to sub-license the Classen Fold-Down patents for LVT products. Classen believed this was a breach of the agreement with Pergo. On that basis, Classen sent a termination notice to Pergo during the proceedings and asked the court to confirm that the termination was valid. On these points, the court found in favor of Pergo and confirmed that Pergo did have the right to sub-license the Classen Fold-Down patents for LVT products, and further declared Classen's termination invalid. 

After this decision, Classen informed Pergo that it would appeal, and has now again tried to terminate the Classen-Pergo agreement. Classen this time has based its termination attempt on grounds different to the first termination attempt. Pergo has informed Classen that it does not accept this new termination and will challenge it in court as well  if necessary. The contract between Pergo and Classen does not give any party the right to terminate the agreement without good reason. Pergo does not believe that Classen has any good reason to terminate the cooperation.  

In the second case, Classen filed suit for infringement of one of its Fold-Down patents against a distributor of LVT products with Fold-Down technology. The LVT products were covered by a sub-license on the Classen Fold-Down patents granted by Pergo to a third party manufacturer. Classen argued that the sub-license was invalid as Pergo did not have the right to sub-license the Classen Fold Down patents under the Classen-Pergo agreement. Based on the finding that Pergo did have the right to sub-license the Classen Fold-Down  patents for LVT products, the products were found to be licensed and the suit was dismissed. Classen was ordered to pay costs. 

Pergo respects the right of Classen to appeal the first instance decisions but is surprised that Classen has sent out press statements suggesting that Classen won the German court proceedings and that there is a question mark over licenses already granted. Pergo believes these are misleading as Pergo's right to license out the Classen rights for LVT has been confirmed and the termination of Classen was found to be invalid. In addition, any existing sub-licenses would in any event not be affected by any potential subsequent termination of the Classen-Pergo agreement.

 

 

Unilin enters into settlement agreement with I4FGP0|#ed37915c-f81f-4523-9434-485eef5d165b;L0|#0ed37915c-f81f-4523-9434-485eef5d165b|Unilin enters into settlement agreement with I4F;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin enters into settlement agreement with I4F2019-11-11T23:00:00Z
Outstanding results of the new Eco Tools® technology implementationGP0|#7fc94dd2-7278-41ba-8cbf-7b062fc2ef65;L0|#07fc94dd2-7278-41ba-8cbf-7b062fc2ef65|Outstanding results of the new Eco Tools technology implementation;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Outstanding results of the new Eco Tools® technology implementation2019-11-03T23:00:00Z
UNILIN and Agfa to show inkjet-printed laminate flooring and furnitureGP0|#1d7b58de-a3dc-468c-91f0-b2bfa37b4bae;L0|#01d7b58de-a3dc-468c-91f0-b2bfa37b4bae|UNILIN and Agfa to show inkjet printed laminate flooring and furniture;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8UNILIN and Agfa to show inkjet-printed laminate flooring and furniture2019-10-16T22:00:00Z
Mohawk reacts on I4F’s meritless lawsuitGP0|#28c99076-2494-4bb4-bd3e-7b0ff8246615;L0|#028c99076-2494-4bb4-bd3e-7b0ff8246615|Mohawk reacts on I4Fs meritless lawsuit;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Mohawk reacts on I4F’s meritless lawsuit2019-05-20T22:00:00Z
ITC orders investigation of US imports of unlicensed vinyl flooring products based on Unilin IP’s recently-filed complaintGP0|#3d11863b-6eb7-4de1-be34-6c2c4a901fac;L0|#03d11863b-6eb7-4de1-be34-6c2c4a901fac|ITC orders investigation of US imports of unlicensed vinyl flooring products based on Unilin IPs recently filed complaint;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8ITC orders investigation of US imports of unlicensed vinyl flooring products based on Unilin IP’s recently-filed complaint2019-05-13T22:00:00Z
Unilin wins important patent case against WindmöllerGP0|#5b1aebe9-5301-4125-bb39-8ada81c6d88f;L0|#05b1aebe9-5301-4125-bb39-8ada81c6d88f|Unilin wins important patent case against Windmoeller;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin wins important patent case against Windmöller2019-05-06T22:00:00Z
Unilin IP files ITC case against unlicensed resilient flooring productsGP0|#f71af1e3-c849-4838-9fb6-540ba7c13940;L0|#0f71af1e3-c849-4838-9fb6-540ba7c13940|Unilin IP files ITC case against unlicensed resilient flooring products;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin IP files ITC case against unlicensed resilient flooring products2019-03-24T23:00:00Z
Unilin obtains notice of allowance for US patent on melamine paper and wood-veneer SPCGP0|#3ca66ec4-fde0-4617-aaef-b6a7e827a696;L0|#03ca66ec4-fde0-4617-aaef-b6a7e827a696|Unilin obtains notice of allowance for US patent on melamine paper and wood veneer SPC;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin obtains notice of allowance for US patent on melamine paper and wood-veneer SPC2019-03-20T23:00:00Z
Unilin’s IP division filed an IPR petition to invalidate I4F’s recently issued US patentGP0|#6415e5c2-83b9-4eff-8dc6-2efc085ae0f0;L0|#06415e5c2-83b9-4eff-8dc6-2efc085ae0f0|Unilins IP division filed an IPR petition to invalidate I4Fs recently issued US patent;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin’s IP division filed an IPR petition to invalidate I4F’s recently issued US patent2019-03-03T23:00:00Z
Unilin files Canadian patent infringement cases for use of bevel and locking technologiesGP0|#c594c90f-f249-4cb4-b0e2-7371b490086c;L0|#0c594c90f-f249-4cb4-b0e2-7371b490086c|Unilin files Canadian patent infringement cases for use of bevel and locking technologies;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin files Canadian patent infringement cases for use of bevel and locking technologies2019-01-20T23:00:00Z
Unilin IP introduces Eco Tools®, a revolutionary method to mill clic profiles.GP0|#262331da-3906-44df-9b20-d01d2e3d8ced;L0|#0262331da-3906-44df-9b20-d01d2e3d8ced|Unilin IP introduces Eco Tools a revolutionary method to mill clic profiles;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin IP introduces Eco Tools®, a revolutionary method to mill clic profiles.2019-01-08T23:00:00Z
Unilin IP introduces Unizip®, a new standard for herringbone glueless installationsGP0|#48dfacef-5253-4721-8732-744b14013b8b;L0|#048dfacef-5253-4721-8732-744b14013b8b|Unilin IP introduces Unizip a new standard for herringbone glueless installations;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin IP introduces Unizip®, a new standard for herringbone glueless installations2019-01-07T23:00:00Z
Unilin IP enters into exclusive partnership with IOBAC on magnetic flooring and walling technologyGP0|#7c2ec294-f01c-40a0-b038-d01efa484511;L0|#07c2ec294-f01c-40a0-b038-d01efa484511|Unilin IP enters into exclusive partnership with IOBAC on magnetic flooring and walling technology;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin IP enters into exclusive partnership with IOBAC on magnetic flooring and walling technology2019-01-06T23:00:00Z
Unilin’s IP division files infringement action against Windmöller in Düsseldorf, GermanyGP0|#1b46efe6-80e6-4dca-a0e6-2d8ff164f76e;L0|#01b46efe6-80e6-4dca-a0e6-2d8ff164f76e|Unilins IP division files infringement action against Windmoeller in Dusseldorf Germany;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin’s IP division files infringement action against Windmöller in Düsseldorf, Germany2018-09-19T22:00:00Z
Unilin files infringement action against Windmöller in Düsseldorf, GermanyGP0|#e35e39f7-d2b2-411a-8e78-9679a7c97437;L0|#0e35e39f7-d2b2-411a-8e78-9679a7c97437|Unilin files infringement action against Windmoller in Dusseldorf Germany;GTSet|#e595ce95-56f9-4a7d-bc08-835022d6ffca;GPP|#762c8738-fe83-44c2-a7dd-fbaa26f8dd15;GPP|#5c9be9e9-3db7-414a-ad34-0f451426485a;GPP|#5e077dbb-73f3-45af-9f7c-0d85bfc04cc8Unilin files infringement action against Windmöller in Düsseldorf, Germany2018-09-11T22:00:00Z